Every few months someone declares the marketing agency dead. It isn’t. But the way businesses buy creative and marketing work is changing, and the evidence is clearer than the headlines. This is my attempt to separate what the data actually shows from what is opinion, and what it means if you run a business or an agency.
A quick note on where I’m coming from: I run an independent creative studio, so I have an interest in this topic. I’ve tried to show the evidence as it is, including the parts that don’t flatter smaller studios like mine.
What the data shows
Agency headcount has fallen
The IPA Agency Census 2025, published in February 2026, found that IPA member agencies employed 24,963 people in September 2025, down 6.8% on the year before. The fall was concentrated in creative and non-media agencies, where headcount dropped by around 14%, and open vacancies fell sharply too.
That is a real contraction. It’s worth adding the context one commentator pointed out: overall headcount is roughly back to pre-pandemic levels. It is a reshaping, not a collapse.
Marketing budgets are growing, not shrinking
At the same time, UK companies have been spending more on marketing. The IPA Bellwether Report recorded upward budget revisions in the first three quarters of 2026, with Q3 the strongest in more than two years according to Marketing Week’s coverage. So the shift isn’t about businesses abandoning marketing. It’s about where the money goes and who does the work.
Agencies are a smaller slice of the budget
Gartner’s 2026 CMO Spend Survey of 401 marketing leaders across North America, the UK and Europe found budgets broadly flat as a share of revenue, at around 7.8%. Agencies accounted for about 19% of those budgets, behind paid media, labour and technology, as MediaPost reported.
AI is changing what clients pay agencies for
Marketing Week’s 2026 Career & Salary Survey of 2,350 marketers found that 14.2% had reduced agency spend as a result of AI over the previous year, against 1.9% who increased it. Among SMEs the figures were 11.3% and 1.5%. Most marketers haven’t changed their agency spend because of AI, but those who have mostly cut it.
Bringing work in-house is established practice
In the US, the Association of National Advertisers reported that 82% of its members had an in-house agency in 2023, up from 78% in 2018. That is a large-company picture and a US one, but it shows how normal it has become for brands to do some creative work themselves.
What analysts forecast
Forrester’s Predictions 2026: Marketing Agencies describes a decade of structural pressure: project work replacing long retainers, more marketing brought in-house, procurement pushing on price, and AI automating production. It predicts further agency job reductions and more consolidation. These are forecasts, not measurements, but they come from people who track the sector closely.
What people in the industry are saying
This is opinion, and I’ve labelled it as such. Marketing leaders quoted by Marketing Week describe budget moving between specialisms rather than disappearing. They mention paying for big retainers where much of the work wasn’t needed, and expecting more outcome-based pricing. A freelancer study reported by Decision Marketing found a third of freelancers felt agencies were relying on them to fill gaps they would once have hired for.
So, is the model changing?
Yes, but not in the way the loudest headlines suggest. Read together, the evidence points to four shifts:
- Less paying for scale for its own sake. Businesses are more willing to buy exactly what they need, when they need it.
- More specialists. Agencies and brands are drawing on specialist people for specific work rather than carrying every skill permanently.
- Leaner structures. AI and better tools let smaller teams produce more, which strengthens the case for experienced people over large teams.
- Direct relationships. Talking to the person doing the work, rather than through layers of account management, is becoming more valued.
When a traditional agency is still the right choice
None of this means agencies are the wrong answer. A full-service or specialist agency is often the better choice when you need:
- A large, multi-channel campaign running across several markets at once
- Significant media buying, where scale and platform relationships matter
- Several senior specialists working at the same time, at volume
- Cover and capacity that one person or a very small studio can’t guarantee
What it means for established businesses
If you’re an established business without a marketing department, the change works in your favour. You’re no longer limited to choosing between doing it yourself and hiring a large agency. You can work with an experienced independent partner who looks after the website, brand, content and growth as one picture, and brings in other specialists when a project genuinely needs them. I’ve written more about what that looks like day to day and about how to decide what kind of help you need.
What it means for agencies
For agencies, the trend makes specialist partners more useful, not less. A reliable specialist for web development, film or technical work lets an agency take on the work without permanent hires. I’ve covered how agencies can outsource that work well.
Where this leaves XPY
XPY is one experienced person working across web, brand, content, growth and systems, bringing in people I trust when a project needs skills outside my own. It isn’t the right fit for every business, and I’d rather say so. If you want to talk through what fits yours, you don’t need a brief, just a conversation. Have a look at how I work as an outsourced creative partner, or get in touch.



