It’s a fair question, and the honest answer is: sometimes. Many established businesses need outside help with their marketing. Fewer need a full-service marketing agency. This guide walks through the realistic options and when each one makes sense, including the cases where an agency really is the best choice.

Start with what you actually need

Before comparing options, be clear about the problem. Most businesses fall into one of these:

  • The website no longer reflects the business, or doesn’t generate enquiries
  • The brand looks inconsistent or dated
  • There is no decent photography or video
  • Marketing happens in bursts, when someone has time
  • Several suppliers are involved and nobody sees the whole picture
  • The business is ready to scale campaigns across several channels

Only the last one points straight to an agency. The others can often be solved more directly.

The five realistic options

1. Do it yourself

Good for: small, contained needs and owners with time and interest. Watch out for: marketing becoming the job that always slips, and a gradual drop in quality and consistency.

2. Hire in-house

Good for: businesses with enough steady, daily work to keep someone busy and the ability to manage them. Watch out for: expecting one hire to be a strategist, designer, developer, filmmaker and analyst at once. Specialist skills still often need to be bought in.

3. Use freelancers for individual jobs

Good for: one-off, well-defined tasks. Watch out for: you become the project manager, joining up the work of several people who may never speak to each other.

4. Work with an experienced independent partner

Good for: established businesses that want one person to look after the website, brand, content and growth as a whole, and to do most of the work. Watch out for: capacity. One person suits a considered client list, not unlimited volume. I cover this in One creative partner or an agency?

5. Appoint a marketing agency

Good for: larger, multi-channel campaigns, significant paid media, PR and situations where several specialists need to work at the same time. Watch out for: retainers that don’t match how your work arrives, and layers between you and the people doing it.

When an agency is the right answer

  • You need several disciplines running at scale at the same time
  • You’re spending substantial sums on paid media and need specialists to manage it
  • You need cover and capacity that a small studio can’t guarantee
  • Your campaigns span several markets, languages or audiences at once

If that is you, a good agency is worth it. Choose one whose team you’ll actually meet.

When you probably don’t need one

  • Your main need is a better website, brand or content, done properly
  • You want to deal directly with the person doing the work
  • Your marketing activity is steady rather than large-scale
  • You’ve paid for retainers before and weren’t sure what you got

That last point is common. In Marketing Week’s reporting, one marketing leader described paying six-figure retainers where, by his estimate, most of the work wasn’t needed. The wider shifts in how businesses buy marketing are covered in Is the traditional agency model changing?

A simple way to decide

  1. Write down the two or three outcomes that matter most this year.
  2. List the skills those outcomes need.
  3. Estimate whether the work is steady, seasonal or project-based.
  4. Decide how involved you want to be.
  5. Pick the lightest option that covers it well, and review in six months.

Where XPY fits

XPY is option four: one experienced person across web, brand, content, growth and systems, bringing in trusted specialists where a project needs them. It isn’t the right answer for everyone, and I’ll tell you if I think something else would serve you better. See the services, read about working with an outsourced creative partner, or start a project. You don’t need a brief, just a sense of what you’d like to change.

Jack Clinton

Author Jack Clinton

More posts by Jack Clinton

Leave a Reply

Share